Table of ContentsView AllTable of ContentsWhat Is AAPI?Mental Healthcare for AAPIThe Need for Culturally Sensitive Treatment
Table of ContentsView All
View All
Table of Contents
What Is AAPI?
Mental Healthcare for AAPI
The Need for Culturally Sensitive Treatment
Close
While it’s safe to say that everyone’s mental health has suffered during the pandemic, it’s also become clear that certain groups have been more impacted than others.
Historically, AAPI communities have been assumed to be a thriving ‘model minority,’ viewed as more highly educated, financially prosperous, and successful compared to other communities of color in the United States. But this harmful and inaccurate stereotype shrouds a far more complex reality. For example, this stereotype ignores the various disparities and structural inequalities that affect different ethnic groups.
Furthermore, the collective assumption of AAPI success can also create a kind of internal pressure for individuals to ignore their mental health or other needs in the pursuit of living up to that image.
AAPI stands for Asian-American Pacific Islander, and is an umbrella term encompassing the diverse identities of people from as many as 50 different countries around the world in regions including East Asia, Southeast Asia, India, and the Pacific Islands.
Therefore, there are many cultural, historical, and other differences and distinctions amongst the AAPI diaspora who are lumped together under this label. Yet it can still be a useful term, particularly given how these groups have shared a history of being othered while living in the United States and can benefit from shared alliances, especially from the work being done on different issues about racism and bias.
Mental Healthcare for the AAPI Community
A recent study found that while the overall mental health of the U.S. population understandably declined during the pandemic, groups including Black, Hispanic, and AAPI were more steeply impacted.
AAPI communities experienced high rates of job loss and hate crimes during the pandemic, yet were also less likely to seek mental health care treatments during the pandemic. The loss of employment (through which many people receive health insurance coverage), mass closure of in-person mental healthcare services, and spiking rates of anxiety, depression, and other mental health issues have combined to create the present circumstance, in which many more people are struggling with mental health yet have less supporting resources and access to care.
However, even before the pandemic, studies have shown AAPIs to be the least likely of all racial and ethnic groups to seek mental healthcare.A recent national study found that only 8.6% of Asian Americans seek mental health services and resources compared to 19% of the general population.Another study reported over a third of Pacific Islanders reporting needing mental health services but few seeking them out due to many barriers.
While the reasons for this hesitancy are numerous and vary between individuals and groups, many AAPIs feel a sense of shame or stigma about receiving mental health services, particularly from Western providers who are less likely to provideculturally sensitive and nuanced treatment. However, there are some positive signs that the situation is changing, as the same study showed that second-generation immigrants are more willing to seek a mental health diagnosis than their parents, which hints at some reduction of the stigma.
Why the Model Minority Stereotype is So Harmful to Asian Americans
This gap in the need for and access to treatment and care points to abroad lack of culturally responsive, racially aware forms of care. Last year, the Asian American Psychological Association presented a written statement at a U.S. House of Representatives hearing regarding AAPI discrimination and violence, detailing the many longstanding barriers to accessing mental and other forms of health care, including language and cultural barriers as well as economic access.
They went on to explain that: “Fear/anticipation of future racism may prevent Asian Americans from accessing needed resources, such as health and mental health care.” It’s important to recognize these barriers and develop innovative solutions, such asonline resourcesand other more accessible tools.
AAPIs also face challenges in obtaining effective treatment in the form of prescribed medication, particularly those used to treat mood and other mental disorders. Eastern modes of treatment and medicine typically differ from Western health practices in a variety of ways. First-generation AAPIs in particular are more familiar with Eastern practices, which often focus on preventative care, spiritual and holistic practices, and what are considered“alternative” remediesin the Western healthcare system.
Because certain remedies, such assome herbal supplements, can negatively interact with or reduce the efficacy of prescribed medications, it’s important to discuss medication at length with patients. An interpreter may be needed to explain contraindications and to ensure that prescribed medications align well with the patients’ ongoing health practices.
Researchers also caution that older Asian immigrants may be less likely to comply with the regular dosage or prescribed regimen, particularly for drugs that must be taken long-term in order to be effective. Again, communicating with patients to ensure understanding of dosage and consistency is vital.
One last issue specific to the AAPI community is the phenomenon of medicines working differently on different people, a field of research also known aspharmacogenetics. Genetic differences can result in different responses to drugs, meaning that a standard dose of a medication may be either too much or too little for an individual person depending on their genetic background. Many clinical trials in the United States still do not account for these genetic differences, spurring researchers to call for the need for more clinical trial diversity.
For example, a recent study reported that Asian-Americans made up only 1.7% of patients in clinical drug trials in which at least 70% of the trial was conducted in the U.S.This means that, until clinical trials become inclusive, doctors should prescribe low doses and carefully monitor AAPI patients’ reactions in order to ensure that patients receive safe and effective treatment.
The issue of pharmacogenetics speaks to a larger issue of AAPIs more generally being neglected in so much of U.S. health research. A 2019 study found that despite being the fastest-growing demographic group in the country, a mere 0.17% of total research funding from the National Institutes of Health went to clinical studies focusing on Asian-American health between 1992-2018.Hopefully, the turmoil of the past couple of years will propel necessary action in redirecting funds and other forms of support addressing AAPI-specific health needs.
A Word From Verywell
The AAPI community face unique challenges in mental health and healthcare. The ongoing stress and difficulties of the pandemic and violence against AAPIs only increase the burden for many.
Collectively working together to acknowledge, heal, and persevere despite anti-Asian racism is a necessary task toward improving AAPI mental health and wellness. Also, as our society becomes more diverse, it’s clear that Western mental health practices need to evolve in order to accommodate cultural, linguistic, socioeconomic, and other differences.
Every person is a complex individual with a unique set of cultural beliefs and practices, and it’s necessary to approach mental health treatment in ways that account for all their nuances—a one-size-fits-all approach is not enough.
Intergenerational Trauma in AAPI Communities
8 Sources
Verywell Mind uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Read oureditorial processto learn more about how we fact-check and keep our content accurate, reliable, and trustworthy.
Thomeer MB, Moody MD, Yahirun J.Racial and ethnic disparities in mental health and mental health care during the covid-19 pandemic.J Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities. doi:10.1007/s40615-022-01284-9
NAMI: National Alliance on Mental Illness.Asian American and Pacific Islander identity and cultural dimensions.
McLean.Why Asian Americans don’t seek help for mental illness.
American Medical Student Association.Mental Health in the Asian Americans/Pacific Islander Community.
Zagorski N.Factors to keep in mind when treating Asian American patients.PN. 2019;54(15):appi.pn.2019.7a20. doi:10.1176/appi.pn.2019.7a20
Asian American & Pacific Islander Health Forum. NYU Center for the Study of Asian American Health.Clinical Trial Diversity Factsheet.
Wong CC Riley.Black patients miss out on promising cancer drugs. ProPublica.
Meet Our Review Board
Share Feedback
Was this page helpful?Thanks for your feedback!What is your feedback?HelpfulReport an ErrorOtherSubmit
Was this page helpful?
Thanks for your feedback!
What is your feedback?HelpfulReport an ErrorOtherSubmit
What is your feedback?
